Lilith

5 September 2008
Tags for this page: 200809 creative reviews
[Site traffic Strip-O-Meter]

Click to censor the Strip-O-Meter.

While attempting to avoid a fire drill at my apartment building, I spent most of today in the University library reading a book I selected by intuition. That's an exercise that has served me well in the past, for instance by providing the seed for my short story He lei nalu ho`okahi in a Hawai`ian dictionary. Today the book I chose was Lilith by George MacDonald. It's from 1895, and available online through Project Gutenberg. It reminded me a lot of my own novel Cross Product and readers who like one will probably like the other.

There's a lot of similarity to some of the work of H.P. Lovecraft - and it shares some of the shortcomings of both Lovecraft's and my own work. The edition I read came with an introduction by C.S. Lewis, who apparently thinks that it's about Christianity. I think it was probably intended to be about Christianity, and there's a lot about redemption in the climactic chapters, but there's also rather more Goddess and a lot less Aslan Jesus than I generally expect from Christian works, so I kind of wonder. That's one of the ways in which it reminded me of my stuff. There are even glimpses of Ima Soko ni Iru Boku, Terry Pratchett's L-Space, and some imagery that sounds an awful lot like it could be from the Waite Tarot, which this book predates. It also predates what the 20th Century feminists did to the Lilith story, though because of all the Christianity (or whatever it is) that's been added, I don't think this book can in any way be said to be an unaltered telling of the old Lilith story. Very interesting stuff, in any case. The same author wrote a lot of other fairy-tale stuff, mostly aimed at younger readers; I at least recognized the title of The Princess and Curdie though I don't think I've read it.

Besides: vampire catgirl. Gotta love that.

Comments

Captain Smokeblower from 75.151.90.142 at Sat, 27 Sep 2008 17:05:46 +0000:
Conservative* U.S. Christians have only recently returned to accepting allegories, such as Aslan in the Narnia series, for the Christ story. I remember as a minister in the late '60s being told, "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe," could not be a Christian story because Mr. Beaver drank beer! Not to mention the Son of God was portrayed as an animal. There may still be holdouts against the Christianity of Lewis' stories because they include magic and (the beautiful) creation story in "The Magician's Nephew," where even a lamp post cross bar comes to life. Just as there are those who reject Harry Potter as being anti-christian for the magic, while ignoring the larger Christian principles of good and evil presented. Lewis wrote about being inspired by George MacDonald's stories in his search for meaning in his life.
*I used "conservative" to mean those who mistakenly assume they believe/follow the Bible literally. And I used the word "assume" because upon careful questioning people reveal that they do interpret what they read in the Bible rather than apply it literally.

New comments are disabled, pending transition to new site code.
Copyright 2008 Matthew Skala
Updates to this site: [RSS syndication file]