Recipe copyright: not such a tasty idea

[Ad box removed; this image serves to flag pages that need to be updated in my log file.]

Here's an article from Food and Wine about the trend towards attempting to attach patent and copyright restrictions to restaurant food.  According to the article, cooks are not at all convinced that such restrictions are a good idea.  So if the food geeks, for whom written-down ideas and fixed expressions are only a small part of the big picture, can recognize that intellectual property is at best a mixed blessing and pretty often a bad idea entirely; then why can't we technology geeks, for whom written-down ideas and fixed expressions are pretty much the whole picture, see the same thing?

I remember several years ago attending a panel discussion on copyright here at the University of Waterloo and asking one of the panelists (paraphrase from memory):  "Okay, suppose Heaven forbid that I'm a big fan of McDonald's hamburgers, and so I go home and try to cook hamburgers myself that will be as close as possible to theirs, and what do you know, I produce a very good imitation McDonald's hamburger, indistinguishable from the ones they might sell me, discernably copies of a McDonald's burger and not a Wendy's burger, and I eat those instead of buying them from McDonald's.  Is that okay?" Yes, it's okay, I was told.  "But am I not stealing the profit they'd get if I bought the burgers from them instead of cooking my own at home?" My point was that making unauthorized copies of materials like CDs, for personal use at home, would be exactly the same thing, and isn't any more "stealing":  the music studios are no more entitled to a profit for the discs I copied, than McDonald's would be entitled to a profit for the hamburgers I copied.  It wasn't their money to begin with and I'm not taking it away from them.  Let them burn the disc or the beef and then talk to me about getting paid.  I didn't mean it to literally refer to food.  I thought nobody would be crazy enough to try to apply it to food.

Looks like I was wrong on that score.

[Ad box removed; this image serves to flag pages that need to be updated in my log file.]

Comments

Close, but no bun. from 24.86.109.110 at Sat, 19 May 2007 21:27:03 +0000:
Only thing is - With music you are taking something that someone else wrote and produced and copying it.

When you're making hamburgers, you are taking raw materials and attempting to recreate that work. You're not "copying" the hamburger (i.e Cloning it to be identical as with CD's)

In your above example, you are from scratch making a "Cover-burger" Similar to the original, more enjoyable in someways but never quite the same.


If you succeed in making your McWannabe Burger :D You will become a punk band of the kitchen.

Add Comment

Your name (required):
Your email address or URL (optional):
Type "bonobo" for anti-spam purposes:

This form is for posting public comments to be read by other people who visit this Web site. If you have a software support question, or other material directed to the page author instead of to the general public, please send email instead.

All the data you enter, and your IP address, will be saved and displayed. Don't enter secret information. HTML is not accepted; it will be displayed as plain text. Your comment will only be added if you enter valid data in all required fields; if it isn't, use the back button and try again.

I, and I alone, reserve the right to remove postings for any reason.

Copyright © 2006, 2007 Matthew Skala
Updates to this entire site: [RSS syndication file]
Updates to this category (copyright) only: [RSS syndication file]